Any victim of violent crime is at a high risk for post-traumatic stress disorder and acute stress disorder.
Victim of Violent Crime Treatment
The type of treatment and counseling a victim of violent crime receives can affect their long-term outcomes. Additionally, research shows as many as 89 percent of victims of violent crimes that are diagnosed with acute stress disorder are also likely to develop post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD).
Dr. Stéphane Guay of the School of Criminology, University of Montreal, Quebec, Canada, and colleagues found that usual care (that is no psychological counseling) involving significant others in early and brief cognitive behavioral therapy helped in preventing depressive symptoms and PTSD in a victim of violent crime.
The study comprised of 166 patients, (59 percent woman), sought to determine whether victims of violent crimes may have better outcomes if a significant other participated with them in cognitive behavior therapy sessions. The participants in the cognitive behavior therapy group had fewer depressive symptoms at 12 months compared with the usual care group.
However, there was no significant difference between the two groups. Nonetheless, the researchers said that the involvement of significant others in therapy merits further research and study.
What Victims Want From Social Services
Globally, resources to assist a victim of violent crime vary widely. One study that highlights this range is Lanying Huang’s examination of victims of violent crimes in Taiwan.
Taiwan is one of the few East Asian countries that are gradually recognizing the need for victim outreach. In a cross-sectional survey of 391 direct victims, and 1617 victims’ families, Huang discovered that there was a large unmet need for counseling services and that the victims of violent crimes who did receive help tended to be more satisfied with the services.
Individuals most likely to be victims were female, (more than 53 percent), 38 percent high school educated, living with a parent or children (45.2 percent), and unemployed (57.7 percent), and had no dependents older than 18 years old (51 percent).
Among the most devastating post-crime conditions were:
- Effect on family life (88 percent)
- Employment (51.6 percent)
- Lowered household income (32.7 percent)
Most troublesome to a victim of violent crime were their reduced income and differences in family dynamics. Victims who took advantage of government services were most likely to use the legal, psychosocial counseling, and financial services.
However, unfortunately, more than two-thirds of those patients surveyed felt that the services provided were inadequate. Individuals who voiced their dissatisfaction with counseling tended to live with a spouse.
They also suffered with post-crime financial difficulties, and they were awaiting a judicial verdict on the crime.
Perception Does Matter to a Victim of Violent Crime
How sexual assault victims perceive themselves can often predict their outcomes according to a survey of 138 undergraduate college women. Respondents who expressed that they were “victims” were more likely to feel shame and post-traumatic stress, whereas respondents, who identified, as “survivors” were angry, yet had fewer depressive symptoms.
Sociologist Kaitlin M. Boyle, PhD, assistant professor at Virginia Tech in Blacksburg explains.
“Explicitly, suggesting that one must think like a survivor, [which] might make someone feel that not only has their agency and autonomy been challenged by their victimization, but that they should be stronger, prouder, more active or healed by now. As a sociologist, I would remind clinicians that healing from trauma is not just about psychiatric components, but about this management of identities.”
Dr. Boyle adds.
“Men may be more resistant to the victim identity because it has associations with stereotypes about submissive femininity and the failure to fight back. A lesbian woman victimized by another woman may hesitate to define her assault as rape because of historical definitions of rape as male-to-female penile penetration. How she labels her assault and herself is shaped by societal stereotypes, and she may hesitate to speak out or seek help for fear of confirming homophobic beliefs about lesbian women.”
“Indirect” Victims Also Suffer
A 40-article systematic review by Jennifer A. Connolly, PhD, professor and director of the psychology undergraduate program at York University in Toronto, Ontario, Canada, and colleagues, found that persons who are co-victims of crime could have multiple negative effects after a family member’s homicide.
In the review, three overall themes emerged:
- Nineteen articles focused on the homicide’s effects on the psychological, social, occupational, and academic functioning of family members.
- Thirteen emphasized how the judicial system affects the grieving process.
- Eight investigated treatment options that helped surviving relatives.
Dr. Connolly notes the following:
“Children can be especially hard hit by this loss and the evidence suggests that adolescents are particularly vulnerable to feelings of loss and guilt. A developmental perspective is important in providing services to children or teenagers as the loss can impact them broadly in school, at home and with their friends.”
Evaluating Rape Crisis Centers
For rape victims, rape crisis centers can ease recovery for victims of sexual violence. Rachel Voth Schrag, PhD, LCSW, assistant professor from the School of Social Work at The University of Texas at Arlington and Tonya Edmond, PhD, professor, associate dean for diversity, inclusion, and equity, School of Social Work, Washington University, St Louis, Missouri, examined how counselors in 83 Texas rape crisis centers formulated treatment goals and assessed the progress of their patients.
Most treatment goals focused on self-esteem, relational functioning, empowerment, trauma, and mental health. Not as many counselors established goals for substance abuse and academic, occupational, and sexual functioning.
And, few counselors relied on standardized measures to assess patients’ treatment progress, which prompted the researchers to advocate for more standardized assessment of the counselors and their patients.
Dr. Voth Schrag offers this advice.
“Clinicians would benefit from using appropriately validated and standardized assessment tools more consistently. This in turn could help guide treatment and provide feedback on intention efficacy.”
Dr. Schrag adds.
“Increasing use of such assessments would not only benefit the treatment planning process and help match evidence-based treatments with survivor needs, but also improve the ability of service providers and agencies to demonstrate the positive impact of their work to service recipients and potential funders alike. Not all assessment tools are developmentally appropriate for survivors at different points in their life course or valid across cultures and contexts. Clinicians should be careful to ensure a match between the survivor they are working with and the assessment tool they are using.”
Psychological assistance, counseling, cognitive behavior therapy, and support from social service and significant others is vital to treating victims of violent crimes.
Help is available, if you’re a victim of violent crime.